Back to ResourcesAssisted Living

Assisted Living vs Nursing Home: Levels of Care Compared

Assisted living vs nursing home: compare care levels, Arizona licensing and 2024 costs, plus how Medicare and ALTCS apply. Free guidance for families.

Options for Senior Living October 28, 2026
Assisted Living vs Nursing Home: Levels of Care Compared

Assisted living vs nursing home comes down to how much daily medical care a person needs. Assisted living provides housing, meals and help with daily activities such as bathing and dressing, while a nursing home provides around-the-clock nursing and long-term medical treatment. Memory care and in-home care sit alongside these two options, and the right fit depends on health needs, safety, budget and personal preference.

What is the difference between assisted living and a nursing home?

Assisted living is a residential setting that combines housing, meals, supportive services and some health care. The Alzheimer's Association describes it as a middle option that "bridges the gap between living independently and living in a nursing home."

A nursing home, also called a skilled nursing facility when it is Medicare-certified, provides "around-the-clock care and long-term medical treatment," according to the Alzheimer's Association. Nursing homes are licensed by the state and regulated by the federal government. The Alzheimer's Association also notes that assisted living is not regulated by the federal government and that definitions vary from state to state.

In practical terms, assisted living is built around a home-like setting with help available, and a nursing home is built around licensed nursing and therapy staff. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) reported that in 2022 about 1,016,400 people lived in residential care communities, which include most assisted living settings, and about 1.2 million lived in the country's 14,700 nursing homes.

How does Arizona license assisted living?

In Arizona, the Arizona Department of Health Services (ADHS) licenses assisted living facilities. ADHS defines an assisted living facility as a residential care institution that provides or contracts for supervisory, personal or directed care on an ongoing basis. It separates these into two sizes: an assisted living home has rooms for ten or fewer residents, and an assisted living center has rooms or units for eleven or more.

ADHS describes three kinds of service:

  • Supervisory care: general oversight, including daily awareness of a resident's functioning and needs, and help with self-administering prescribed medications.
  • Personal care: help with daily living activities, including coordinating intermittent nursing and having licensed nurses give medications and treatments.
  • Directed care: programs and services for people who cannot recognize danger, call for help, express needs or make basic care decisions.

This matters when comparing communities. Two Arizona assisted living communities can be licensed for different levels of service, so a family should ask which service level a community holds and whether it matches the person's current needs.

What are the main levels of care compared?

Here is a plain-English comparison of the five options families most often weigh.

  • Independent living: housing for adults who do not need daily help, usually with meals, activities and transportation. The Alzheimer's Association describes retirement housing as offering limited supervision along with social activities and transportation.
  • Assisted living: help with daily activities, medication support, meals and housekeeping in a residential setting.
  • Memory care: specialized residential care for people with Alzheimer's disease or another dementia. The National Council on Aging (NCOA) says eligibility generally involves a dementia diagnosis and a need for around-the-clock supervision, and that memory care units usually have locked doors and staff with dementia-specific training.
  • Skilled nursing facility or nursing home: round-the-clock nursing, rehabilitation therapy and long-term medical care.
  • In-home care: aides or nurses who come to a person's own home for a set number of hours.

The Alzheimer's Association explains that memory care is often an Alzheimer's special care unit within another residential community, such as assisted living. Some units are locked and some are not, so it is worth asking about security and staff training during a tour.

Who needs assisted living, and who needs a nursing home?

People often move to assisted living when they need regular help with daily activities but not constant nursing attention. The CDC reported that in 2022 about 62% of residential care community residents needed help with three or more activities of daily living, and about 44% had ever been diagnosed with Alzheimer disease or another dementia. Bathing (75%) and walking (71%) were the most common needs.

A nursing home is more often the right fit after a hospital stay that calls for rehabilitation, or when someone needs ongoing skilled nursing, such as complex wound care or frequent clinical monitoring. A 2003 federal study from the Office of the Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation found that nursing home residents tend to be lower-income, older and more severely disabled, and that assisted living may substitute for nursing homes for some older adults.

A doctor, hospital discharge planner or geriatric care professional can assess what level of care a specific person needs. This article cannot make that decision for any individual.

How much does each level of care cost?

The 2024 Genworth and CareScout Cost of Care Survey, which drew on more than 15,000 provider surveys collected from July to December 2024, reported these national median annual costs:

  • Assisted living: $70,800 per year
  • Nursing home, semi-private room: $111,325 per year
  • Nursing home, private room: $127,750 per year
  • Home health aide: $77,792 per year
  • Adult day care: $26,000 per year

These are national medians for 2024. Arizona and Phoenix prices may differ, so for local figures see our guide to assisted living costs in Phoenix, Arizona. NCOA, citing 2023 data, put memory care in assisted living at about $6,160 per month, which is higher than standard assisted living because of added supervision and staffing.

Does Medicare pay for assisted living or a nursing home?

Medicare does not pay for assisted living. Medicare.gov states that Medicare generally does not cover long-term care or custodial care unless medical care is needed.

Medicare Part A does cover a limited stay in a Medicare-certified skilled nursing facility. According to Medicare.gov, the rules include an inpatient hospital stay of at least three days in a row, entering the facility within about 30 days of leaving the hospital, and a need for daily skilled nursing or therapy. For 2026, Medicare.gov lists $0 per day for days 1 through 20 after the Part A deductible of $1,736, then $217 per day for days 21 through 100. After day 100, you pay all costs.

Can Arizona's Medicaid program help pay for care?

The Arizona Long Term Care System (ALTCS) is Arizona's Medicaid program, run by the Arizona Health Care Cost Containment System (AHCCCS), for people with age-related, physical or intellectual and developmental disabilities who need nursing facility level of care. AHCCCS states that people who qualify do not have to live in a nursing home, and that many members live in their own homes or in assisted living facilities and receive services there.

ALTCS has both medical and financial eligibility rules. AHCCCS publishes the application and guidance, and a qualified elder law attorney or benefits advisor can explain how the rules apply to a specific family. Our team can also point you toward the right starting place.

How do families choose the right level of care?

A simple process can lower the stress of the decision.

  1. Ask the person's doctor what kind of help is medically needed now and what is likely to be needed in the next year or two.
  2. List daily activities where help is needed, such as bathing, dressing, medications, meals and mobility.
  3. Check safety concerns, including wandering, falls and nighttime needs.
  4. Set a monthly budget and learn which benefits may apply.
  5. Tour more than one community and ask what happens if care needs increase. Our guide to questions to ask when touring assisted living can help.

Many families find it useful to choose a community that can adapt as needs change, so a second move is less likely.

Frequently asked questions

Is assisted living cheaper than a nursing home?

In the 2024 Genworth and CareScout survey, the national median for assisted living was $70,800 per year, compared with $111,325 for a semi-private nursing home room. Costs vary by location and by the services a person needs.

Can someone move from assisted living to a nursing home later?

Yes. Needs can increase over time, and some people move to a nursing home or skilled nursing facility if they need more medical care than an assisted living community is licensed or staffed to provide. Asking about a community's discharge and care-level policies before moving in helps families plan ahead.

Is memory care the same as assisted living?

No. Memory care is specialized residential care for people with Alzheimer's disease or another dementia, and it usually adds secured spaces and dementia-trained staff. Many memory care units are located within assisted living communities.

Does Medicare cover a nursing home stay?

Medicare Part A covers a limited stay in a Medicare-certified skilled nursing facility after a qualifying hospital stay of at least three days, for up to 100 days per benefit period. It does not cover long-term custodial care.

Does Arizona Medicaid cover assisted living?

The Arizona Long Term Care System (ALTCS) can cover services for people who meet medical and financial eligibility rules, and AHCCCS says members may receive services in assisted living facilities or at home. Eligibility depends on individual circumstances.

Sources

  • Alzheimer's Association, Types of residential care: https://alz.org/residentialfacilities?lang=en-US
  • Arizona Department of Health Services, Assisted Living Provider Types: https://hsapps.azdhs.gov/ls/sod/ALProvTypes.aspx
  • CDC, Residential Care Community Resident Characteristics: United States, 2022: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/db506.htm
  • CDC FastStats, Nursing Home Care: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/nursing-home-care.htm
  • Genworth and CareScout Cost of Care Survey 2024 (InsuranceNewsNet): https://insurancenewsnet.com/oarticle/genworth-and-carescout-release-cost-of-care-survey-results-for-2024
  • Medicare.gov, Skilled nursing facility (SNF) care: https://www.medicare.gov/coverage/skilled-nursing-facility-snf-care
  • Medicare.gov, Long-term care: https://www.medicare.gov/coverage/long-term-care
  • AHCCCS, ALTCS: Coverage for Individuals with Long-Term Care Needs: https://www.azahcccs.gov/Members/GetCovered/Categories/ALTCS.html
  • NCOA, What is Memory Care?: https://ncoa.org/adviser/local-care/memory-care
  • ASPE, Estimates of Risk for Long-Term Care in Assisted Living and Nursing Home Facilities (2003): https://aspe.hhs.gov/reports/estimates-risk-long-term-care-assisted-living-nursing-home-facilities

Call us for a free consultation at 602-845-1320. Our team offers personalized guidance at no cost to families.

This article is general information and not medical, legal or financial advice. Please consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Topics
assisted living vs nursing homelevels of senior carememory care vs assisted livingArizona assisted living licensingdoes Medicare cover assisted livingALTCS assisted livingOptions for Senior Livingsenior placementsenior living advisor